1 for 1 debate

[bwfcdan94]

if you could have kept one player from last season that we lost at the expense of loosing a member of our squad for next season who would it be
(side note: the 2 players must play in the same position for example loose zat knight regain gary cahill)

[Jez]

well yeah, zat knight for cahill, not much better than that is there?

[a1]

stuart holden in for darren pratley

piece of piss

[Hoboh]

Owen Coyle for Gary Meg...

[bwfcdan94]

Owen Coyle for Gary Meg...

i honestly would take that if someone offered me that now

[YtarmyYtarmy]

Ngog for John McGinley

[TKIZ!]

Owen Coyle for Gary Meg...

i honestly would take that if someone offered me that now

Really? Why? Just honestly interested to know

[Puskas]

Ngog for John McGinley

I thought it was people who'd left this season?

If not, Kevin Davies for Trevor Morgan. Or Steve Elliot. Or Wayne Entwistle. Or a sack of potatoes.

[bwfcdan94]

Owen Coyle for Gary Meg...

i honestly would take that if someone offered me that now

Really? Why? Just honestly interested to know

because coyle managed to achieve something near impossible that megson couldnt - relegate us, i honestly belive the season he lost his job ( i saw him just minuites after he was sacked outside the reebok with all his stuff in his arms waiking to his car) he would have just kept us up but only just mind

[truewhite15]

Owen Coyle for Gary Meg...

i honestly would take that if someone offered me that now

Really? Why? Just honestly interested to know

because coyle managed to achieve something near impossible that megson couldnt - relegate us, i honestly belive the season he lost his job ( i saw him just minuites after he was sacked outside the reebok with all his stuff in his arms waiking to his car) he would have just kept us up but only just mind

I don't think he would have done, but that's by the by. He would probably have taken us down the season after though. In contrast, Coyle kept us up comfortably that first season, and then we spent the first 3/4s of last season dancing in the top half. Megson would have never gotten us there. Whether Megson would have kept us up last season is debatable, but I happen to think he wouldn't have done.

[Relentless09]

bwfcdan94 for Batman

[bwfcdan94]

Owen Coyle for Gary Meg...

i honestly would take that if someone offered me that now

Really? Why? Just honestly interested to know

because coyle managed to achieve something near impossible that megson couldnt - relegate us, i honestly belive the season he lost his job ( i saw him just minuites after he was sacked outside the reebok with all his stuff in his arms waiking to his car) he would have just kept us up but only just mind

I don't think he would have done, but that's by the by. He would probably have taken us down the season after though. In contrast, Coyle kept us up comfortably that first season, and then we spent the first 3/4s of last season dancing in the top half. Megson would have never gotten us there. Whether Megson would have kept us up last season is debatable, but I happen to think he wouldn't have done.

i think he would as alot of the players we have are his rather than coyles, look at coyles signings you all go on about robbie blake being a waste of space and eagles being s**t, then there is ngog and everybodies favourite baldie darren pratley. if coyle had of signed just one very good player instead of those four we would have stayed up simples. :negative: better than http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2009/10/ ... 34x437.jpg

[bwfcdan94]

bwfcdan94 for Batman

i still dont really know who this batman bloke is but from what i gather he is a massive WUM

[plymouth wanderer]

i think he would as alot of the players we have are his rather than coyles, look at coyles signings you all go on about robbie blake being a waste of space and eagles being s**t, then there is ngog and everybodies favourite baldie darren pratley. if coyle had of signed just one very good player instead of those four we would have stayed up simples. :negative: better than http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2009/10/ ... 34x437.jpg[/quote]


That's George Clooney

[truewhite15]

Pratley's shite, I'll grant you. Eagles is actually useful. And, as has been pointed out numerous times, there's a difference between signing players and getting them to play. We might have been shit last season, fair enough. But we were shit ALL THE TIME under Megson. When Coyle gets the team to play, they play a damn sight better than they ever could under Megson. If signing players was all there was to it, we'd have a scout as a manager.

Oh, and your point about signing one "very good" player instead of the 4 you mention. Bullshit. If he had done that, we'd have been fecked a long time before the last day of the season, because our squad would have been nowhere near sufficient to carry us through.

[bwfcdan94]

i think he would as alot of the players we have are his rather than coyles, look at coyles signings you all go on about robbie blake being a waste of space and eagles being s**t, then there is ngog and everybodies favourite baldie darren pratley. if coyle had of signed just one very good player instead of those four we would have stayed up simples. :negative: better than http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2009/10/ ... 34x437.jpg

That's George Clooney[/quote]

who mistakingly fell out of a plane on the way to manchester airport and landed in burnley terrified

[bwfcdan94]

Pratley's shite, I'll grant you. Eagles is actually useful. And, as has been pointed out numerous times, there's a difference between signing players and getting them to play. We might have been shit last season, fair enough. But we were shit ALL THE TIME under Megson. When Coyle gets the team to play, they play a damn sight better than they ever could under Megson. If signing players was all there was to it, we'd have a scout as a manager.

Oh, and your point about signing one "very good" player instead of the 4 you mention. Bullshit. If he had done that, we'd have been fecked a long time before the last day of the season, because our squad would have been nowhere near sufficient to carry us through.

no i am pressuming that these are the tones giving off by this forum, IMO eagles is one of our best players, pratley is great as well as is the case with ngog but blake well he is below par at best

[truewhite15]

Pratley's shite, I'll grant you. Eagles is actually useful. And, as has been pointed out numerous times, there's a difference between signing players and getting them to play. We might have been shit last season, fair enough. But we were shit ALL THE TIME under Megson. When Coyle gets the team to play, they play a damn sight better than they ever could under Megson. If signing players was all there was to it, we'd have a scout as a manager.

Oh, and your point about signing one "very good" player instead of the 4 you mention. Bullshit. If he had done that, we'd have been fecked a long time before the last day of the season, because our squad would have been nowhere near sufficient to carry us through.

no i am pressuming that these are the tones giving off by this forum, IMO eagles is one of our best players, pratley is great as well as is the case with ngog but blake well he is below par at best

Hang on a bloody second. You said, and I quote;

i think he would as alot of the players we have are his rather than coyles, look at coyles signings you all go on about robbie blake being a waste of space and eagles being s**t, then there is ngog and everybodies favourite baldie darren pratley. if coyle had of signed just one very good player instead of those four we would have stayed up simples

So you're using them as a stick with which to beat Coyle in your support of Megson, in terms of transfers, saying that if we'd signed one great player instead of them, we'd have stayed up, and you imply that Megson would have signed said player.

But then you say that three of the players you mentioned are the best players at the club. You've been definitively found out as a bullshit merchant, my son.

[YtarmyYtarmy]

Ngog for John McGinley

I thought it was people who'd left this season?

If not, Kevin Davies for Trevor Morgan. Or Steve Elliot. Or Wayne Entwistle. Or a sack of potatoes.

Sorry didnt read the first part of the thread fully, but i suppose it Cahill back for Knight, end of topic for me.

[bwfcdan94]

Pratley's shite, I'll grant you. Eagles is actually useful. And, as has been pointed out numerous times, there's a difference between signing players and getting them to play. We might have been shit last season, fair enough. But we were shit ALL THE TIME under Megson. When Coyle gets the team to play, they play a damn sight better than they ever could under Megson. If signing players was all there was to it, we'd have a scout as a manager.

Oh, and your point about signing one "very good" player instead of the 4 you mention. Bullshit. If he had done that, we'd have been fecked a long time before the last day of the season, because our squad would have been nowhere near sufficient to carry us through.

no i am pressuming that these are the tones giving off by this forum, IMO eagles is one of our best players, pratley is great as well as is the case with ngog but blake well he is below par at best

Hang on a bloody second. You said, and I quote;

yes megson signed this now champ league winner from sheffield called gary cahill

i think he would as alot of the players we have are his rather than coyles, look at coyles signings you all go on about robbie blake being a waste of space and eagles being s**t, then there is ngog and everybodies favourite baldie darren pratley. if coyle had of signed just one very good player instead of those four we would have stayed up simples

So you're using them as a stick with which to beat Coyle in your support of Megson, in terms of transfers, saying that if we'd signed one great player instead of them, we'd have stayed up, and you imply that Megson would have signed said player.

But then you say that three of the players you mentioned are the best players at the club. You've been definitively found out as a bullshit merchant, my son.

i have jumped from popular opinions that i disagree with to my opinion that you all disagree with